Plus-Size Cardigans: Open, Buttoned or Kimono? Decide by the Front
A cardigan has no front to fasten, or it has a row of buttons, or it is basically a long open panel. That choice matters more than the knit, because the front decides how the piece hangs over a bust and across the hips.
I picked three DressMePlus cardigans that handle the front three different ways. I'm going from the listings and photos only. I haven't worn any of them.
Why the front matters more than the size label
Wikipedia defines a cardigan as a knitted garment with an open front, worn like a jacket, with or without buttons. That is a loose definition, and the three styles below behave differently once you put them on.
An open front never has to close, so the bust measurement matters less and the length and sleeve matter more. A buttoned front is the reverse. If the buttons pull or gap across the fullest part of the chest, the whole cardigan fights you all day. A kimono front has no buttons and no real structure, so it hangs from the shoulders and the fabric weight does the work.
Before you pick, hold up your own best-fitting cardigan and note three things: whether you close it, where the hem ends against your hip, and how wide the sleeve is at the upper arm. Then compare each listing against those.
Three cardigans, three ways to close the front
The Knitted Bat Sleeve Open Front Pocket Sweater Cardigan is the cozy one. In the photo it is a rust or burnt orange, a chunky knit with a wide draped collar, two big patch pockets and sleeves that gather in thick ribbed cuffs. It hangs open, with no buttons, to somewhere around mid-thigh. The listing says orange, bat sleeves and an open front, so the photo and the text agree. A knit this thick will add bulk, and bat sleeves add more at the upper arm. Check the sleeve and the hem on the size chart before you worry about the bust.
The Leopard Print Button Up Long Sleeve Cardigan Coat is the one that does the most work. The photo shows a tan and brown leopard print with a plain V-neck, no collar and a full row of round silver-tone buttons. It runs past the hip, close to mid-thigh, and falls straight down. The fabric looks thin and matte, more like a fine knit than a thick coat, even though the title says coat. The listing calls it a regular fit and describes a short dress length, which does not quite match the longer line in the photo, so rely on the length number in the size chart. Buttons are the thing to test here. If you're wide through the bust or hip, measure those two spots against the chart, because a buttoned front shows every inch of strain.
The Boho Floral Long Sleeve Open Front Kimono Cardigan is the lightest of the three. The photo shows a long, open, flowing piece in a dense teal and cream floral print, with wide sleeves and a hem that reaches about mid-thigh. The listing offers beige, green and navy and calls it a spring and summer piece, so read the color swatch before you assume the teal from the photo is what you'll get. It's a layer for a plain tank or tee rather than a replacement for a warm cardigan. Because it has no closure at all, it suits anyone who wants coverage without anything pulling across the chest. The tradeoff is that the fabric is light and loose, so it won't hold a shape and it won't keep you warm.
Check these before you order a cardigan
Run through this list with the listing open next to your own measurements.
- Decide whether you'll close it. If yes, compare the bust and hip numbers on the size chart with your own. If no, skip straight to length and sleeve.
- Match the hem to what's under it. A hem that stops above the hip looks deliberate over high-waisted bottoms and awkward over a long top. A longline hem needs to clear the widest part of the hip, or it will flip open when you walk.
- Check the sleeve width at the upper arm. Batwing and kimono sleeves are cut wide on purpose, but a wide sleeve still needs room at the cuff if you push it up.
- Look at the fabric in the photo, not just the title. Two of these three have names that suggest more bulk than the photo shows. Thin knit drapes. Chunky knit holds its shape and adds volume.
- Read the color options in the listing. A photo shows one color, and the listing may offer others.
If you're between sizes in a chunky or buttoned cardigan, take the larger one. You can roll a sleeve or leave a front open, but you can't add inches across a button band.


